leonarski_fandClaude Opus 5.5
1fd28672bb
The null is nine fixed-seed random orientations of the model, each placed by the same rigid body as
the real fit and fitted to the data AS MERGED. Where the indexing probe reindexed the data to the
model's, the model's solution against the merged data is its twin-related orientation - and more
generally the crystal looks the same from every orientation the lattice's rotations (the space
group's, composed with the twin laws) take the model to. A draw within the rigid body's reach of one
of those is walked onto it and is not a sample of the null.
On 5epe (F 2 3, twin law y,x,-z, 24 equivalent orientations) replicate 8 of 9 was drawn 7.9 deg from
one of them; the rigid body moved it 7.9 deg, held-out R-free 0.53 -> 0.20, R-work 0.197 against
0.56-0.58 for the other eight. The null's sd became 0.125 and the crystal's own model read +0.01
sigma, DOES NOT FIT, so the indexing it had decided at +25.8 sigma was refused and the files kept the
merged indexing (R-free 0.52). This happens on every binary whose indexer picks the other hand.
The fix is at the draw, not the score: a draw whose angle to the nearest equivalent orientation is
under the rigid body's reach is drawn again from the same generator, so everywhere no draw falls
there the nine rotations - and every output - are exactly the ones before. The reach is the rotation
about the centroid that moves the model's rms-radius atom by the ladder's first zone (6 A, or d_min
where coarser): 18.7 deg on 5epe, whose other draws sat at 21.7 deg and beyond and did not converge.
Twin laws come from the lattice (ReindexAmbiguityOperators on the data cell and group) regardless of
whether the probe ran. Redraws are capped at 1000 so that a model small enough for the reach to cover
the whole of SO(3) takes its draws as they come instead of looping.
Scoring the real model against the best of both hands instead was not taken: the real fit is
already scored in the hand that wins, and the contamination is in the null, not in the real fit.
Measured, battery commands with --model, rc173 27e154e5d vs this:
5epe 1 redraw; DOES NOT FIT +0.01 -> FITS +55.86 sigma (null 0.5730 +- 0.0072); indexing
decided at +40.4 sigma and reindexed y,x,-z; R-free 0.5246 -> 0.1749 (deposited 0.1671)
9fhc 1 redraw (reach 8.8 deg; the replaced draw had not converged); files byte-identical,
MODEL_FIT_SIGMA +201.27 -> +199.39, verdict unchanged
9hnc, 8sa8, 8xtg, 9bn8: no redraw; p.hkl, p.mtz, p.cif (bar the audit date), p_maps.mtz,
p_model.cif and the model-validation report byte-identical
[ModelValidation] tests pass.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01D1G8gJVAy6gp1K5Dz3NE5C
Jungfraujoch
Application to receive data from the PSI JUNGFRAU and EIGER detectors.
All documentation is now placed in docs/ subdirectory and for the current version hosted on Jungfraujoch Read The Docs page.